Seattle university school of law digital commons seattle university school of law digital commons faculty scholarship 111994 jurisprudence of successful treason. Moreover, the study gives a fairly adequate impression of the school of legal theory that has evolved under the influence of kelsen,or rather of the schools for not all of kelsen. Once it is read in the context of kelsen s political works, kelsen s conception of legality provides the basis for a notion of political legitimacy. Kelsen s doctrine of the identification of law and state held the legal order of the modern state to be the pattern of every legal system. Reine rechtslehre first published 1934 quoted in paulson, the neokantian dimension of kelsen s pure theory of law, above n 1, 328.
Kelsen s monistic theory of law, according to which international and municipal law have the same subjectmatter, paved the way for the dominant contemporary doctrine. To free the concept of law from the idea of justice is difficult. In his book pure theory of law, hans kelsen aims to provide a holistic definition of law by embodying a comprehensive analysis of legal normativity and systematic structures. Grundnorm where all other norms are related to each other by either being inferior norms. The continuing influence of kelsen on the general perception. It is an attempt to separate the elements of legal theory. This edited collection commences with a comprehensive introduction which establishes the character of kelsen s critical engagement as a general critique of natural law combined. But there always a groundnorm like a written constitution or the. According to kelsen the pure theory of law is called likewise because it only. This book argues that kelsen s pure theory of law needs to be read in the context of kelsen s political theory.
The general theorf published at harvard is, as kelsen says, intended to re. Pdf hans kelsen pure theory of law majd rashyd academia. Kelsen s theory of grundnorm or pure theory of law is not a balanced view of law because it onl y focused on the coerciveness of legal norm. On one hand, it marks the most defined development to date of analytical positivism. General theory of law and state, by hans kelsen, translated. Hans kelsen s pure theory of law is the most prominent and influential legal theory for continental law systems. The theory is best known in its development in the allgemeine staatslehre 1925, trs. In 1925 professor kelsen published his allgermeine saatslehre, summarizing in systematic form the contributions made. To remove the difficulty which arise by the fact that international law does not losses all the characteristic of law especially the appearance of compulsion he says that it is comparable to primitive law. Kelsen s strict separation of law and morality, in chapter two of pure theory of law, was an integral part of his presentation of the pure theory of law. Kelsen proffers a theory of law not a rule of decision. In particular, the article examines kelsen s ideas on the primacy of international law, the necess ary demise of the concept of sovranity and. Translation from the second german edition by max knight. Hans kelsen, the theory of law and the international legal.
Theories are made in order to govern or to guide a man to live their lives in a lawful manner but these are not self alone able to run a legal system because there is only one lawgiver who has the power to create laws for the humanity. Hans kelsen s theory of revolutionary legality furnished the primary doctrinal vehicle to reach. It is charged that kelsen s theory is betrayed, on its own terms, if it is put to normative use as a practical principle for guiding judicial decision and action. Kelsen s doctrine of the identification of law and state held the legal order of the modern state to be the pattern. Rechtslehre or pure theory of law, hans kelsen, 1992, law, 171 pages. Kelsen distinguishes his pure theory of law from both traditional. The issues dealt with feature under various headingsalbeit always prominentlyin the national schools of legal theory. A single test which proves some piece of theory wrong is more valuable than a hundred tests showing that idea might be true. Philosophical study of hans kelsens thoughts on law and satjipto. He also says about the normative behaviour which takes validity from the ground norm. Summary of hans kelsens pure theory of law hugh mccarthy. Hani kelsen the theory of law and the international legal system.
Kelsen s theory of law, as well as on the general european situation in legal philosophy out of which the theory of kelsen has grown. Kelsen distinguishes his pure theory of law from both traditional natural law theory and traditional legal positivism, and instead identifies his theory as a middleway between the two traditional theories. Kelsen recognized that groundnorm need not be same in every legal order. The international law is in early stages of and in future will have all the characteristic which the modern law has it. It is an attempt to separate the elements of legal theory in a.
The law, kelsen maintained, is basically a scheme of. A landmark in the development of modern jurisprudence, the. His major works on legal positivism were the general theory of. Kelsen and hart on the normativity of law 1 introduction the problem about the normativity of law that is, the problem of accounting for the nature of the legal ought, the law s normative force, or, if you will, the. Har ts theory is more convincing than him becaus e. Pdf hans kelsens pure theory of law is the most prominent and influential legal theory for continental law systems. Introduction as was the case during much of his life, the austrian legal philosopher hans kelsen 18811973 is still best known today for his pure theory of law reine rechtslehre. Conclusionsthe pure theory of law and contemporary. Pdf hans kelsen on international law semantic scholar. This theory of positive law is then presented by kelsen as forming a hierarchy of laws which start from a basic norm, i. Instead, kelsen suggested a pure theory of law which would avoid. Hans kelsen s pure theory of law is a positivist theory that has been enormously influential in the world of jurisprudence.
And law is a means, a specific social means, not an end. Mar 14, 2005 in this article the author follows the argumentative ascent of the vienna school of legal positivism, and especially of hans kelsen, as concerns the intellectual topos of law contrary to law. This edited collection commences with a comprehensive introduction which establishes the character of kelsen s critical. There are familiar questions connected with explaining legal. This theory has rejected the idea of natural law in society. The theory is pure because it separates jurisprudence from other disciplines like ethics, politics and psychology. Tayyab mahmud jurisprudence of successful treason coup d\u00e2\u0080\u0099etat and common. The present paper purports to provide an analytical reconstruction and critical assessment of such a critique. A theory itself is an abstract idea that comes from a human mind. The dynamic theory of law is the explicit and very acutely defined. Pdf legality and legitimacy in hans kelsens pure theory of. This article focuses on hans kelsen s theory of international law and pacifism. Hart, and many other legal theorists of the past century1 is the idea that law is a normative system, and that any theory about the nature of law must focus on its normativity. Tayyab mahmud jurisprudence of successful treason coup d.
Part one surveys the fundamentals of kelsen s argumentative strategy against natural law and its theorists. Kelsen s book contains only text neither logical notation nor pictures. Moreover, the study gives a fairly adequate impression of the school of legal theory that has evolved under the influence of kelsen,or rather of the schools for not all of kelsen s disciples. Introductionhans kelsen 1881kelsen 1973 austrian jurist and philosopher of law. Hans kelsen on international law francois rigaux abstract kelsen s monistic theory of law, according to which international and municipal law have the same subjectmatter, paved the way for the dominant contemporary doctrine. In the first paragraph of pure theory of law, kelsen introduces his theory as being a theory of positive law. Pure theory of law was expounded by hans kelsen and is a part of analytical positivism. Pdf legality and legitimacy in hans kelsens pure theory. Hans kelsen 18811973 was a leading germanamerican legal posi tivist. The application of the law, in order to be protected from moral influence or political influence, needed to be safeguarded by its separation from the sphere of conventional moral influence or. Hans kelsens pure theory of law by tim murphy ssrn.
Pdf kelsens pure theory of law naveed hussain academia. The theory of hans kelsen represents development in two directions. The kelsen s pure theory of law is considered as a reaction against the idea and working of modern schools, as the modern schools have opened the boundaries of jurisprudence to such a limit that they are now co terminus with that of social science. Pure theory of law does not talk about the nature and origin of grundnorm. The philosophical foundations on which the pure theory of law is constructed are conceptions of general philosophic interest. However, they can only be emotionally held subjective opinions. Professor kelsen s theory of law and government is styled a pure theory of law reine rechslehre, with the accent on the word pure. Hans kelsen and the natural law tradition provides the first sustained examination of hans kelsen s critical engagement, itself founded upon a distinctive theory of legal positivism, with the natural law tradition. Doctoral dissertation, university of toronto philosophy, 2006. Kelsen is known for the most rigorous development of a positivist theory of law, i. Hans kelsen, the theory of law and the international legal system. Paulson, on the puzzle surrounding hans kelsen s basic norm, above n, 283. Kelsens validity theory and its transcendental application will be discussed further below.
This essay first sets out the epistemological basis of the pure theory in cognition of the law, that is, on how exactly law is perceived and recognized. The general theorf published at harvard is, as kelsen. Following an analytical reconstruction of kelsen s theses, the author makes a number of critical observations. Pdf visualization of hans kelsens pure theory of law. Kelsen theory can be interpreted in the light of the quotation given below. The pure theory of law stanford encyclopedia of philosophy. This failure caused kelsen to turn towards a new form of international legal argument that has been accurately characterized as pragmatic, but that also retained key features of his earlier international law. It argues that the pure theory is best understood as an attempt to find a middle ground between natural law and legal positivism that may serve to reconnect positivist legal thought in a distinctive and so far unexplored way with normative political theory. Hans kelsen is considered to be one of the foremost legal theorists and philosophers of the twentieth century.
The pure theory of law and analytical jurisprudence edisciplinas. Part of the common law commons recommended citation recommended citation tayyab mahmud. The dynamic theory of law is singled out in this subsection discussing the political philosophy of hans kelsen for the very same reasons which kelsen applied in separating its explication from the discussion of the static theory of law within the pages of pure theory of law. Tayyab mahmud jurisprudence of successful treason coup. Kelsen puts forth the argument that the basic norm is presupposed when an individual chooses to interpret the actions of authoritative officials in a normative way.
This concluding chapter once again takes up the question of what form of legal theory we find in kelsen. In a series of essays published from the late 1920s up to the mid1960s, hans kelsen carried out a radical critique of natural law theory. The most important feature of kelsen s theory is grundnorm. Law, morality, religion while recognizing law as the specific social technique of a coercive order, we can contrast it sharply with other social orders which pursue in part the same purposes as the law, but by quite different means. According to kelsen, laws are scattered in the society which creates. Kelsen also thought that law s commands are directed most fundamentally. Kelsen has limited perspective regarding law he says the task of law is not justice, but maintenance which totally negates the real function of law. Hart, and many other legal theorists for legal normative systems kelsen called the basic norm grundnorm oing ssay his on orget utline elsen heory irst articularly he ature.
Hans kelsen 18811973 austrian jurist and philosopher of law. Hans kelsen was an austrian legal theorist, who worked in germany until the rise of the nazi party, and then in the usa. His writing made an important contribution to many areas. Once it is read in the context of kelsen s political works, kelsen s. Formal theory confined to a particular system of positive law as actual in operation.
In particular, the article examines kelsen s ideas on the primacy of international law. Kelsen s pure theory is about the hierarchy of norms. A talk norberto bobbio and danilo zolo 1 meeting kelsen d. He published the first edition of the pure theory of law in 1934, and a second, expanded edition which i read in 1960. Mar 21, 2016 theory of norms not so much concerned with the effectiveness of legal norms. Kelsen, an analytical jurist, in his pure theory of law says, law is the norm which stipulates sanction. Hans kelsen s pure theory of law and its doctrine of the grund norm has achieved a. Kelsen states that the pure theory provides the fundamental principles by means of which any legal order can be comprehended and that it is a general jurisprudence. Legality and legitimacy in hans kelsen s pure theory of law. It follows from the second axiom that two laws, neither of.
1212 1686 709 1580 36 317 229 428 225 1392 714 1816 883 1341 1212 863 940 411 1817 502 1681